Too Faced Pumpkin Spice Palette Review

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, which means I make a small commission when you make purchases through them.

Product Details

The Too Faced Pumpkin Spice Palette is a fall-themed palette with a variety of mostly warm and a few cool toned shades. Out of the 18 shades, 12 of them are matte and the rest are shimmers. There is a total 12.6 grams / 0.43 oz and it retails for $49.

The palette is made of metal and has a magnetic closure just like many of Too Faced’s previous palettes in the same format. The eyeshadows have a moderately strong, very sweet, pumpkin pie-ish scent with maybe a hint of spice.

Formula Overview

The matte shades are highly pigmented and adhere very well to the lid. They take a bit of patience to blend fully but they do blend out nicely. This type of formulation is nice for those that enjoy wearing looks that have a lot of color variation without the colors muddying together. They weren’t too soft/powdery in the pan nor were they too firmly pressed. For the most part the mattes seemed pretty consistent in quality from shade to shade, though I did find You Spicy  required a bit more time and effort to apply evenly. Very little fallout from the mattes.

There are a few different types of shimmers in here. Falling For You is a standard shimmer with a softer, more satiny finish. Crisp is similar but also has very fine micro glitter shot through the formula. The micro glitter does fall out a bit under the eyes during application.

Fall Vibes is the most highly reflective but it is also a flakier type of shimmer. It had a significant amount of fallout that I was able to brush away because my base was pretty heavily powdered. It adheres incredibly well to the lid, to the point where it can be tricky to blend out. This was best applied by building it up slowly rather than going in heavy right away. Oh My Gourd is similar to Fall Vibes but a had a slightly “creamier” feel to it.

Wanna Piece Of Me? is an interesting shade. It yielded a sparkling finish in the photos but, in person, this seems to also give a satin finish if applied heavily and smoothed over. It had a lot of fallout.

PSL & Chill has blue and fuchsia micro glitter and gives a sparkling finish both in photos and in real life. This also had a lot of fallout.

Shade Selection

One of the reasons I decided to go ahead and pick this palette up was the versatile color selection. I can see this working for more than just fall with the colors included. There is enough range from light to dark and a variety of hues to work with. I also personally love the matte to shimmer ratio.

Wear Time

Wear time was consistent all 5 times I wore this. I wore looks 1-5 for about 8 hours and had moderate creasing by the end of each day. This is pretty average for me.

Swatches

Looks

Look #1:

• Whipped Cream – Inner corner, brow bone
• Fall For It – Inner crease, inner lower lashline
• Pumpkin Spice – Outer crease/transition
• Ginger Spice – To add depth to outer crease
• Warm & Cozy – Outer lid, outer lower lashline
• Fall Vibes – Center of lid

Look #2:

• Whipped Cream – Inner corner, brow bone
• Sweetie Pie – Transition, inner lower lashline
• Spice Spice Baby – Inner/outer lid, outer lower lashline
• Cocoa Drizzle – Tightline, eyeliner on outer part of lid
• Falling For You – Center of lid

Look #3:

• Whipped Cream – Inner corner, brow bone
• Love You A Latte – Transition, lower lashline
• You Spicy – Crease
• Spice Of Life – Inner/outer lid
• Crisp – Center of lid

Look #4:

• Whipped Cream – Brow bone
• Crisp – Inner corner
• A La Mode – Transition
• Fall For It – Inner crease
• Cocoa Drizzle – Oute rlid/crease, outer lower lashline
• Pumpkin Spice – Inner lower lashline
• Fall Vibes – Center of lid

Look #5:

• Whipped Cream – Brow bone
• Love You A Latte – Transition, inner lower lashline
• Warm & Cozy – Outer lid/crease, outer lower lashline
• PSL & Chill – Center of lid
• Oh My Gourd – Inner lid
• Wanna Piece Of Me – Lower lashline, inner corner

Look #6:

• Sweetie Pie – Transition, lower lashline
• Cocoa Drizzle – Outer lid/crease
• Devinah Cosmetics Celesta – Center of lid, lower lashline

This shimmer on the lid is a single from Devinah Cosmetics Galaxy Dust Shifters Collection. The shades in that collection seem to compliment this palette pretty well, so that is what I did here. It looks like an intense yellow gold here but this shade also has a green shift that was more noticeable in real life.

Look #7:

• Spice Of Life – All over the lid, crease, and lower lashline
• PSL & Chill – Center of lid

I also used PSL & Chill in Look #5. You can probably see that the shade looks different in each photo. This photo is a bit out of focus and edited to help bring out the blue and fuchsia sparkles that I can see in this shade in real life.

Look #8:

• Whipped Cream – Brow bone
• Pumpkin Spice – Transition
• Ginger Spice – Inner half of lid
• Warm & Cozy – Outer half of lid and lower lashline
• Sweetie Pie – Inner lower lashline
• Devinah Cosmetics Cygnus – Center of lid
• Terra Moons Cosmetics Sun Sign – Inner corner

Both shimmers in this look are singles from indie brands.

Look #9:

• Spice Of Life – Inner/outer lid and crease
• Pumpkin Spice – Center of lid and crease
• Love You A Latte – Transition (you can barely even see it)
• Fall Vibes – Applied lightly all over the lid for more of a sparkly effect
• Terra Moons Cosmetics Io – Inner corner

Look #10:

• Whipped Cream – Inner corner, brow bone
• A La Mode – Transition, lower lashline
• Warm & Cozy – Outer lid and crease
• Oh My Gourd – Center of lid